|
Reader Comments
Totally disagree with the reviewer in this - 3 out of 10 would suggest that this is drivel, and it's not. I'm not sure where the reviewer felt the guitar went flat, but the opening track oozes energy. I don't think the singer is as hit and miss as you claim, with Vindicated playing to the sensitivity the review talks about.
What I find odd is the scale of the rating - I follow CR reviews closely, in particular a lot of the UK indie bands, and I can't work out how this gets 3/10 compared to a lot of the other output over the past year. From reading the review (and comparing to other 2,3 star reviews), it's not clear how the reviewer came to the conclusion of such a bad rating.
I know that having different reviewers will result in a variation in the scale of ratings given, but I think this is really disproportionate compared light of other reviews.
I'm disappointed with the review, and to anyone reading it - ignore it. Up the score by at least three (and add an extra point for Vindicated), and you're in a better ball park.
I agree with the other two.... totally!
You only other rating this bad you have given recently was to David Gibbs so I listened to some of that ep to compare with Cartoon Break up and to put it nicely I don't thing these two eps should have the same rating!
I have also noticed that generally you either like a band and give them 7/8 or you dont like them and give them a 4(or sometimes 3!)
Sure this ep doesn't sound as good as say Noel Robinson who you gave a 9. But they are an up coming band on a smaller budget and amounts of time. I'm sure prelude understand this themselves but that said it is in no way a bad ep!
I would give it a 6 or 7! But you have just decided, because they have more restraints than say Noel, to slate it!
Honestly I had a small opinion of these reviews before but now......!
I hope you review their latest recording, sometime this year maybe?, and correct the opinion of those few people who actually respect your views!
If you have read that review, visit www.myspace.com/preludeonline and see what they are actually like!
Will end the rant here but could go on and on....
Prelude deserve much better.
another thing..
you gave them a 3 out of 10??
Why??
There Outstanding..
I Dont understand...
=] That all =D
Hahahahahahaha. How stupid do you have to be to write such things about prelude?? There a fantastic band and you are so wrong. Theyre songs do NOT lack character and the singing "fails to convince" does it?? Pfft. Prelude are better anyone and everyone so i hardly believe ther singing FAILS!! Yeah i may be 14 but i know good music when i hear it and this is it. Arnt older people ment to be more clever and brainier?? Just shows how wrong adults can be sometimes!! "Shame the guitar goes concrete and flat in the chorus, tending to kill it off" Ha! CONCRETE?? FLAT?? Did you actually LISTEN to the song?? I think not.
HARSH comments. Totally disagree! Think the songs rock, the lead vocalist is fantastic and that these guys will go places.
Well, well, well. Yet another track that clearly was not listened to properly. You can't even get the lyrics right. Please listen to the latest track. Yes I did say listen to it. Scoring out of ten I would have given them a 7-8. But then thats just me!